The fans think that Cassie Randolph's alleged boyfriend, Brighton Reinhardt, released a new song called "Creep" that is about The Bachelor star Colton Underwood. In 2019, Bachelor Nation got to watch former NFL player Colton Underwood leading The Bachelor season 23 and attempting to find love on the show. He had plenty of great options, and ended up with a Final 3 that consisted of Cassie Randolph, Tayshia Adams, and Hannah Godwin. In the end, Colton chose to propose to Cassie, and their engagement lasted about a year.
But things took a turn in May 2020, when The Bachelor stars Cassie and Colton announced that they were going their separate ways. At a surface level, this felt like just another Bachelor break-up that the fans expect from many of the couples formed on the show. However, things quickly took a turn in the months that followed as Cassie obtained a restraining order against Colton, and he suddenly wiped his Instagram clean. Overall, Cassie claimed that Colton harassed her and was tracking her location at all times.
Now, The Bachelor fans on social media platforms like Reddit are starting to think that Cassie Randolph's alleged new beau Brighton released a diss track all about Colton Underwood. The song in question - which is called "Creep" - includes the chorus, "You're a creep / You can't stop thinking about her." But even more specifically, the fans find that this particular lyric reveals the Colton connection: "You can't stop thinking about my baby / What once was yours in the world, is changing / God, I hope you get your thinking right / GPS on the underside / Told her everything will be just fine / Damn, I can't believe these guys." For one, the lyrics make it clear that Brighton is singing about an ex-boyfriend of his current girlfriend. Secondly, the restraining order that Cassie obtained against Colton was after he allegedly placed a GPS tracking device inside her car. You can listen to the full song below.
Furthermore, the possible clues/references don't end there, as Bachelor Nation also finds potential connections to the Cassie and Colton drama in lyrics like, "I know that you might think that she's the one that got away / Put a tracker in her whip just to watch her pump the brakes / And if you wanted all the tea, well, I don't got much time to say / Lying, cheating, playing games, it's everything you calculate." Still, Cassie and Brighton have kept their alleged relationship pretty private, so it's always possible that this song has nothing to do with this drama. With that said, all of these references and lyrics feel extremely direct and pointed, so it would be interesting to hear an explanation as to what else they could mean other than being a diss track about Colton.
The drama never ends when it comes to Bachelor Nation. Hopefully, both Cassie and Colton are in a better mental space in 2021.
The Bachelor season 25 airs Mondays at 8 pm ET/PT on ABC.
Sources: Reddit