The One Tree Hill Podcast, hosted by the stars Hilarie Burton, Sophia Bush, and Bethany Joy Lenz, has continued to thrive for over a year now. The stars continue to give insight into what the popular series was about and all the behind-the-scenes moments with special guest stars.
Ultimately, the podcast continues to succeed because the show continues to be revisited by fans even years after wrapping up its final season. The series has had its fair share of tear-jerking moments and drama-filled storylines. In the end, there are many episodes fans will revisit because they are some of the best.
Season 2: "I Will Dare" (8.8)
In this high-rated episode, Felix makes his way into the friend group by convincing everyone to a "dare night," which includes a scavenger hunt that tests their limits.
This episode is rated so highly because it's very memorable and fun. Fans enjoy watching episodes where the gang gets together and steps out of their comfort zones to relax a bit a try to step away from the drama. The series is usually high stakes, and it is good for the characters to be normal teenagers once in a while. This is a good episode because it's heartfelt and shows the soft sides of the characters.
Season 3: "How Resurrection Really Feels" (8.9)
This fan-favorite episode features Haley, Brooke, and Peyton spending a day in jail for stealing back Brooke's designs from a clothing store she works at. They get bailed out by Lucas, who is still heartbroken over Brooke.
Meanwhile, Nathan and Chris Keller go on a reluctant road trip to get money back from a poker game. This is another episode that tests the characters when they find themselves in situations they thought would never happen. It also highlights some aftermath of the previous episode and what each character has gone through.
Season 5: "For Tonight You're Only Here To Know" (8.7)
This episode takes place after the time jump, where the characters find themselves back at Tree Hill high school. Lucas and Skills coach the basketball game while Mouth does the announcements just like old times. Meanwhile, the girls are trapped inside of the library during the game, which causes tensions to arise.
This season five episode is memorable because of how Peyton deals with Lucas choosing Lindsey. There is tension and drama in this episode that leads the girls to open up while facing their own inner turmoils and insecurities. There is still a lot on the line for the boys as they fear they won't live up to Whitey's coaching.
Season 1: "Every Night Is Another Story" (8.8)
In one of the best episodes from season 1, brothers Lucas and Nathan are still butting heads and find themselves at the mercy of their rival basketball team after being kicked off the bus after a fight. Haley and Peyton bond over taking care of a drunken Brooke.
This is another episode that features the girls and the boy separately and how they come together. The episode is told out of order on the same night and gives the sense that drama will unfold regardless. This episode allows the characters to spend more time together since they are essentially stuck with one another. The audience gets a sense that their relationships will grow stronger, and they do.
Season 3: "When It Isn't Like It Should Be" (8.6)
Rachel invites the gang over to her family's cabin, where drama and shenanigans ensue. Nathan plans on proposing to Haley while she hides that she lost her ring. Brooke and Lucas reunite to help Haley and Nathan, while Mouth and Rachel are still at odds.
This entertaining episode guides the main characters together and while bringing their issues to the surface. There are also funny moments and heartfelt scenes that fans always go back to. It does end with a proposal, and many surprises are revealed. In the end, there are many things happening in this episode that will keep the viewer interested.
Season 4: "It Gets Worse At Night" (8.5)
Mouth is sent to jail overnight, where he explains to a group of prisoners his relationship troubles. The rest of the gang agree to go on a road trip to Texas to get him, and they eventually find themselves crashing another high school's prom. This episode gets references a lot among fans because it's the episode the characters bond together to save Mouth in the most hilarious way.
It is a mission just for them to get to Texas, and they have a funny encounter with Chris Keller. There are many hilarious and wholesome quotes throughout this episode that fans might . This is also a sweet episode for Haley and Nathan fans. Things are coming to an end for the characters as the end of high school seems to be near. The characters seem to be tying up loose ends, which works overall for the stories in the end.
Season 4: "Pictures Of You" (9.3)
A class assignment pairs up the characters with one another in order to get to know who they truly are. It's a classic episode that gets to the bottom of secrets and desires of each character and takes place through the entirety of this highly rated season 4 episode With each pairing comes deep and meaningful conversations about being young and what they truly didn't know about the other.
It tests stereotypes in high school and tackles the idea that there is more than meets the eye. Fans might recognize this episode as the episode Brooke and Chase get paired up, and he learns all the insecurities that face someone like Brooke, who seems to have it all. It also reveals Lucas and his true ion for writing.
Season 3: "The Show Must Go On" (9.3)
One of the show's favorite couples, Nathan and Haley gather their friends and family for their second official wedding. However, reveals about the dealership fire, Deb's homicidal intents, and Karen's lamentations over Kieth keep things interesting.
The characters have gone through a lot in this season, and this episode wraps up many issues the characters faced. There is a lot of drama surrounding Peyton, Lucas, and Brooke. There is also the chaotic relationship between Rachel and Cooper. In the end, emotions run high and leave the audience with a devastating cliffhanger.
Season 4: "Some You Give Away" (9.6)
In this season 4 episode, it's the state championship game where the stakes are higher than ever. Haley fears something is wrong with her baby, its Whitey's last game to coach, and Nathan is threatened over throwing the game. The best ship of season 4, Lucas and Peyton have a great moment.
This is one of the most memorable episodes because so many things are happening at once. There is enough drama and heartfelt moments that keep fans on the edge of their seats for the entirety of the episode. The winning moment makes all the hard work and tears worth it as the storylines are wrapped up. However, just as everything seems to be going well, a devastating moment sees Hayley get hit by a car after pushing Lucas out of the way, and fans are left on a cliffhanger as to her status.
Season 3: "With Tired Eyes, Tired Souls, We Slept" (9.7)
After being bullied by classmates, Jimmy Edwards returns to school with a mission and a gun. This incredibly dark episode features the characters secluded in various rooms in the school while never knowing when the terror will end and who will come out alive.
The series deals with several serious life issues, but nothing was more terrifying than the school shooting. It was handled extremely well, and it opened up conversations about bullying, mental health, safety, and relationships. This event changed the trajectory of the series, and most of the characters were dealing with repercussions for several seasons after it happened.