Summary

• The Winchesters is a prequel to Supernatural that delves into the early lives of Sam and Dean's parents and their relationships with other hunters. Unfortunately, it was canceled after its first season.
• Evil is a show that puts a twist on the demon-hunting premise of Supernatural, featuring a team investigating reported demon possessions. The show continues to scare and thrill fans on Paramount+.
• Preacher offers a replacement for Supernatural's Biblical horror aspects, following a preacher with immense powers and the various supernatural beings who want to possess him. Fans will appreciate the show's concluded storyline.

Fantasy shows like Supernatural have become one of the most popular subgenres on television in the last few decades. The show took the ideas from The X-Files, with its Monster of the Week mixing with a larger mythology, and combined it with the urban fantasy of shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer. What resulted was a show that entertained fans for 15 seasons, one of the most successful genre television shows in network television history. The entire premise was simple, with Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean Winchester (Jensen Ackles) battling demons, monsters, and angels, to protect humanity at all costs.

When Supernatural ended its run, sending Sam and Dean Winchester into the sunset, it took away one of the most popular supernatural primetime shows from fans. With the series featuring angels, demons, and hunters coming to an end, fans might need a new series to dig into. Whether finding something brand new for television or going back in time to a classic, there is plenty of great supernatural television to watch for anyone who misses Supernatural. This also includes plenty of options that are very similar, with angels, demons, gods, and monsters of the week to satisfy anyone who misses Sam and Dean's hunting trips.

All 15 Seasons of Supernatural are available to stream on Netflix.

25 The Winchesters (2022-2023)

Stream on Max

There aren’t a lot of shows like Supernatural that line up exactly with its premise. A family who hunts supernatural creatures and explores urban legends might sound like a broad genre premise, but the series has a lot of unique lore. Building on that same lore, and sometimes, turning it on its head, is The Winchesters. The Winchesters is a prequel to Supernatural that focuses on Sam and Dean’s parents early in their relationship and the friendships they have in the hunting community. Fortunately for fans, it’s only 13 episodes and a quick watch. Unfortunately for fans, it was canceled after that first season.

24 Evil (2019- )

Stream on Paramount+

Premiering in 2019 on CBS, Evil is great for fans of shows like Supernatural because it takes the same general idea, but adds a nice little twist to it. Instead of two demon-hunting brothers, it has a priest, a forensic psychologist, and a tech guy setting out to find out if reported demon possessions are real or not. If they are real, it is up to this team to deal with the problem and eliminate the demons. However, the fun part here is watching the team interact and figure out what is real and what is not. The show moved to Paramount+ for its second season and continues to scare and thrill fans, with Evil season 4 now on the way.

23 Preacher (2016-2019)

Buy on Amazon, AppleTV, and Vudu

For fans who miss the Biblical horror aspects of shows like Supernatural, Preacher might be the perfect replacement series. The best news is that the show has already concluded, so fans can sit down and watch the complete story from start to finish. The AMC series is about a preacher who ends up with a force from Heaven called Genesis taking residence in his body that gives him immense powers. This paints a target on him, with everyone from supernatural killers, religious fanatics, and angels from Heaven all wanting him for their own reasons, playing into the same angles as Supernatural's mythology.

22 Salem (2014-2017)

Stream on Hulu

Salem was a supernatural horror series that ran from 2014 through 2017 on WGN America. It was a period drama that was based around the Salem Witch Trials and took into consideration that it wasn't just mass hysteria, but that there were real witches on hand during this time. Fans of Supernatural got their fair share of witches throughout its run. It also had plenty of magic, although mostly from angels and demons. The idea in Salem is that one of the witches wanted to summon the Devil himself, which caused a lot of problems fans of shows like Supernatural might recognize.

21 Legacies (2018-2022)

Stream on Netflix

For unique takes on mythology, Legacies is probably one of the closest to Supernatural fans will find. The Vampire Diaries spin-off series focuses on a boarding school for supernatural beings, so the hunting aspect doesn’t apply. The show does take a meta approach to some of its storylines though. Fans who like the alternate reality episodes of Supernatural, or the ones that focus on the fandom of the show, will enjoy similar episodes in Legacies. There’s even a musical episode that retells the history of The Vampire Diaries.

20 Reaper (2007-2009)

Stream on ABC

There was a lot to love about every season of Supernatural, but one of the things that fans liked best was the brotherly relationship between Sam and Dean Winchester. This allowed the supernatural series to add a lot of humor to the horrific elements. For fans who loved the humor found in shows like Supernatural and want a replacement, the supernatural comedy Reaper might give them what they are looking for. Instead of Lucifer tormenting Sam and Dean, this series has the Devil trying to get to know his son a little better while priming him to take over the job.

19 American Gods (2017-2021)

Stream on Starz

While shot in a much more elaborate and colorful manner than shows like Supernatural, the Starz series American Gods shares a lot in common with it. Based on the novel by Neil Gaiman, this series focuses on a man named Shadow Moon who is taken in by Odin to do his bidding. This leads to Shadow meeting all sorts of supernatural beings, from elder gods to Leprechauns, all with the idea that a war is coming with the new gods of the world, very familiar grounds for fans of shows like Supernatural. The first season of American Gods is still the best, but there were three seasons of the godly series for fans who want more supernatural action.

18 Angel (1999-2004)

Stream on Hulu

Between Angel and Buffy, the former leans toward the feel of shows like Supernatural. Angel is both dark and funny, it changes themes and locations, and it wasn't afraid of stretching its limits. Granted, Angel is frustrating when it comes to formats. Those who only watched the first and last seasons would probably be confused. Still, the core of the show involves either a mystery of the week or, as the seasons progressed, multi-episode arcs where the gang dealt with supernatural beings of every shape and size.

17 Friday The 13th: The Series (1987-1990)

Unavailable to stream

While it has no connection to the movie series of the same name, this show certainly had its moments of horror. However, they were mixed with fantasy and humor to make the syndicated program easier to digest for viewers. Friday the 13th: The Series focuses on a pair of antique shop owners. Along with their friend Jack, they work to recover cursed antiques, so they can be returned to a shielded vault. It was popular enough to garner several Emmy nominations. This plays more like the Monster of the Week episodes of Supernatural and brings in lots of variety as well.

16 Charmed (1998-2006)

Stream on Prime Video

Charmed got a reboot series in 2018, and though both shows focus on a magical trio of sisters, the original is much closer in its exploration of different magical beings to Supernatural than the newer series is. The Halliwells learn about their magic late in life because their memories have been altered from their childhood, so they don’t have the same knowledge of the supernatural world that Sam and Dean do growing up. The family dynamic, however, is what the series is truly built around. Their exploration of some of the most ridiculous aspects of the supernatural world is aided by their unflinching loyalty to one another, even when one of them is turned into a creature they should vanquish, much like Supernatural.